单位文秘网 2021-08-21 09:02:36 点击: 次
摘 要:循证方法作为一种具有突出实证与规范特质的跨学科研究方法,激发了法学界深入探索的兴趣和深度应用的动力。文章对为什么是“法循证学”而非“循证法学”的学科命名,以及法循证学的内涵与外延、方法特征、方法论意义、研究前景等内容进行了论述。研究认为,将Evidence-based Law命名为“法循证学”,是基于法学领域内新兴交叉学科概念界定的科学根据和事实依据的考量;法循证方法具有方法的科学性、目标的靶向性、知识的系统性等特征;法循证学方法不但呈现出让法治决策有据可依等一般意义,而且,对中国特色法治还具有独特的实践和理论意义;受循证方法在医学进而在社会科学领域不断推进的影响,将循证方法引入法律问题的分析评价与法治决策过程,将是中国法循证学的未来发展趋势。
关键词:法循证学;循证方法;循证社会科学;循证医学;法治决策
中图分类号:DF0-059;C3 文献标识码:A DOI:10.11968/tsyqb.1003-6938.2018039
Evidence-based Law:An Inter-discipline and Approach between Law and Evidence-based Science
Abstract Evidence-based approach, as an inter-discipline and approach between law and evidence-based science, inspires both the interest and the initiative of the law community to further explore and deepen its application in law research and legal decision-making by its outstanding characteristics of empirical and rigorous study.The paper focuses on the definition of the evidence-based law in Chinese law context and its reason behind and evidences below, the connotation and denotation of the evidence-based law concept, its methodological characteristics and meanings for social science research especially law. It concludes that the Chinese name of the evidence-based law is based on the consideration of both the scientific criterion and linguistic facts of the concept definition of new inter-disciplinary subjects and approaches such as the law and economics etc. which have happened in the law field;the evidence-based law approach is an inter-disciplinary paradigm with features such as scientific methodology, targeted objects and systematic knowledge etc.;the evidence-based law approach shows not only the general meaning to the evidence-based legal decision-making, but also some specific practical and theoretical significance?to the rule of law with Chinese characteristics; influenced by the unceasing development of the evidence-based approach firstly in medicine then in social science, Chinese law arena will gradually introduce the evidence-based law approach in analyzing and evaluating legal issues and making legal policies in the near future.
Key words evidence-based law; evidence-based approach; evidence-based social science; evidence-based medicine; legal decision-making
互聯网和大数据叠加的新时代,不仅为法学研究提出了许多新挑战,更为法律问题的解决提供了新方法与可能。法学作为面向社会实践的社会科学研究领域,必须始终铭记问题导向的研究宗旨和服务法治决策的制度归宿。传统法学研究大多注重定性的价值论研究,即使有定量和实证倾向的制度法学、分析实证方法,也缺少必要的途径、技术和手段来直接回应现实法治决策的有效需求。而背靠临床实验数据(其后演化为互联网大数据)的循证方法(Evidence-based Approach),一经与传统医学联姻为循证医学(Evidence-based Medicine,EBM 1992)[1],就显现出了其强大的生命力和创新力。在医学领域功成名就的循证方法,又很快在包括法学在内的国际社会科学领域尤其是英语社会科学领域大显身手[2]。虽然,国内学界对此问题的关注、跟踪和研究与国际相比时滞不大,而且,中国在循证医学领域还取得了国际瞩目的成就,但是,汉语社会科学领域尤其是法学领域的研究却呈现出:点(循证矫正)有余而面(法学法律领域的循证)不足、学(循证技术)有余而思(法循证方法论)不足;研(文献计量学分析)有余而践(法治循证决策)不足等发展特征与生存现状。
(责任编辑:单位文秘网) )地址:https://www.kgf8887.com/show-235-86655-1.html
版权声明:
本站由单位文秘网原创策划制作,欢迎订阅或转载,但请注明出处。违者必究。单位文秘网独家运营 版权所有 未经许可不得转载使用